Chapter 2 - The Toys in the Forbidden Study, the Little Girl Who Asked Why He Never Smiled, and the Photograph That Should Not Have Existed
By Monday morning, the study had changed again. A small wooden bookshelf stood near the window, its lowest shelf filled with books about animals and trains. Mia ran toward it as though it had been waiting for her all her life. I watched Vincent watch her, and I noticed the exhaustion beneath his eyes.
He had slept badly. I could tell from the untouched coffee beside his keyboard and the way he rubbed the bridge of his nose when he thought nobody was looking. Renzo, normally cheerful, was even quieter than usual.
“Is everything all right?” I asked while straightening the sofa cushions.
Vincent looked up. “Why wouldn’t it be?”
“Because you haven’t told Mia her dinosaur is anatomically impossible.”
For one second he seemed surprised. Then his mouth twitched. “It has nine legs today. I’m choosing my battles.”
Mia held up the drawing. “Dragons need extra feet for dancing.”
“Of course they do,” he said.
I wanted to believe the tension was ordinary business. Yet two unfamiliar men had arrived at the estate before breakfast, and Renzo had escorted them through the side entrance rather than the main hall. The guards changed shifts twice in one hour. A car with darkened windows waited beyond the fountain, engine running.
At ten, Vincent asked me to bring Mia to the kitchen. He had a meeting. I gathered the crayons and noticed a photograph on his desk, face down beside an unsealed envelope. I did not touch it. But I saw the corner of a red coat and a child’s small white shoe.
Later, in the laundry room, Signora Bellini, the senior housekeeper, warned me not to mistake Vincent’s kindness for permission to become familiar.
“Children are charming until they become a problem,” she said. “And Mr. Castellano has already buried enough problems.”
The cruelty of the sentence startled me. “Mia isn’t a problem.”
“I didn’t say she was. I said you should remember your place.”
I returned to work with heat in my cheeks. I knew my place very well. It was a rented apartment above a dry cleaner, a stack of overdue bills, and a daughter who needed a new winter coat every year because she refused to stop growing.
Vincent’s kindness had made that place easier to bear, but it had not changed it.
That afternoon, Mia announced that she wanted to draw a happy picture of Vincent. He was reviewing contracts at his desk. “You will need a great deal of yellow,” he said without looking up.
“Why?”
“Apparently yellow is the official color of happiness.”
Mia considered him. “Then why don’t you smile?”
The room went silent.
Renzo stopped turning pages. A guard shifted near the door. I looked up from the vase I was arranging, ready to intervene.
Vincent set down his pen. “Sometimes people forget how.”
“That’s silly,” Mia said. “You just do this.”
She pulled the corners of her mouth upward with both index fingers. Her expression was so absurd that Renzo laughed before he could stop himself.
Vincent studied her. “That looks uncomfortable.”
“Practice,” she ordered.
He obeyed, badly. She corrected him with the seriousness of a surgeon. By the time she declared him improved, even the guard by the door was smiling.
Then Mia asked, “Did someone make you sad?”
Vincent’s expression changed. He looked at the photograph on the shelf. “Yes.”
“Did they say sorry?”
“No.”
Mia climbed onto the sofa beside him. “My mommy says some people don’t know how to say sorry. You can still have cookies.”
He laughed then, a real laugh that seemed to surprise him more than anyone. “Your mother sounds wise.”
“She knows everything except where my purple sock goes.”
I felt the room turn warm around us. For a moment the world outside the estate disappeared.
The next day, a woman arrived in a cream-colored coat and high heels that clicked across the marble like a warning. Her name was Celeste Armand. I knew her from old society photographs in the library: Vincent’s former fiancée, the daughter of a wealthy developer whose companies still did business with the Castellanos.
She entered the study without knocking. “Vincent, darling. We need to discuss the foundation gala.”
Her eyes found Mia on the rug. Then me.
“How charming,” she said. “You’ve opened a nursery.”
Vincent didn’t stand. “Celeste.”
“Renzo told me you were busy. I assumed he meant with adults.”
Mia looked up. “Who are you?”
“Someone who knew Vincent before you did.”
“That’s okay,” Mia replied. “You can still be nice.”
Celeste’s smile sharpened. “And who taught you to speak to strangers?”
“My mommy.”
“Then perhaps your mommy should teach you when to be quiet.”
I stepped forward. Vincent was faster.
“Celeste,” he said, his voice flat, “you are a guest. Act like one.”
She blinked. I saw a flash of genuine shock. Perhaps nobody had corrected her in that room before.
“I was joking.”
“Then choose better jokes.”
She turned to me. “Take the child out.”
Vincent’s gaze hardened. “You don’t give orders to my staff.”
I gathered Mia’s pencils and left before the argument could become worse. In the corridor, my daughter asked why the pretty lady sounded angry.
“Sometimes grown-ups are having a difficult day,” I said.
“Then she needs practice too.”
I kissed her hair. I wished practice could solve everything.
That evening, I stayed late to prepare guest rooms. The house was nearly empty when I carried fresh towels past the study. Vincent’s door stood ajar. He was speaking to Renzo in a voice I had never heard before.
“The date is wrong,” Vincent said. “I stood beside their graves. I identified the bodies.”
“Records can be altered,” Renzo answered. “You know that better than anyone.”
“Not this. Not without someone inside the family helping.”
I stopped. I should have walked away. Instead, I heard a name.
“Isabella,” Vincent whispered.
He said it the way a person might touch a wound to make sure it was still there.
Renzo replied, “The child in the photograph could be her. But the image might have been taken earlier and dated later.”
“Then prove it.”
I backed away before they noticed me. My pulse hammered. I had seen the little girl in the framed photograph. Isabella. I had assumed she was a niece, a cousin, perhaps a family friend. I had never imagined Vincent might have lost a child.
At home, after Mia fell asleep, I opened the small metal box where I kept the few belongings my husband had left behind. His name was Daniel Bennett. He had worked as a driver for a private transport company. The police told me he died in a collision caused by a drunk motorist. I had accepted the report because I was pregnant, frightened, and exhausted.
But there had been details I could never explain. A stranger had visited the hospital the night Daniel died and asked whether he had spoken before the crash. A week later, someone had slipped an envelope of cash beneath our door. I returned it to the address on the note. The address did not exist.
I took out Daniel’s watch. Its back was scratched. He had worn it every day, and the clasp had been repaired twice. Inside the box was a folded receipt from a repair shop in the city. On the reverse, in Daniel’s handwriting, were two words: CASTELLANO / EAST.
I had seen them before. I had assumed they referred to a delivery route. Now, sitting beneath the weak light of my kitchen, I wondered why my husband had written the name of the family I worked for.
I told myself it was a coincidence. There were many Castellanos in the city. Daniel had transported equipment for construction firms. Yet my fingers would not stop shaking.
The following morning, I asked Renzo whether Vincent had ever employed a driver named Daniel Bennett. Renzo’s face changed so quickly that I knew the answer mattered.
“Why?” he asked.
“He was my husband.”
Renzo glanced toward the study. “Sophia, don’t ask that question in the hall.”
I felt the floor tilt beneath me. “You knew him?”
“I knew of him.”
“Did he work here?”
Renzo lowered his voice. “There are things I need to check before I can answer.”
“That sounds like an answer.”
He looked pained. “I’m trying to protect you.”
I stepped away. “People keep saying that when they don’t want to tell me the truth.”
Before he could respond, Mia appeared carrying her purple dinosaur drawing. She announced that Vincent had promised to judge a contest between dragons and horses. Renzo stared at her for a long moment, then smiled sadly.
“Your daughter has excellent timing,” he said.
At lunch, Vincent summoned me to his study. Mia sat at the window with her crayons. Renzo closed the door behind me.
Vincent held a photograph of a young man beside a white delivery van. “Is this your husband?”
I recognized Daniel immediately. He was laughing, head tilted back, one hand resting on the van door. I had never seen that photograph.
“Yes,” I whispered. “Where did you get it?”
Vincent looked at Renzo, then back at me. “He worked for a transport company contracted to my family. Three years ago, he made a delivery on the night my wife and daughter died.”
My mouth went dry. “My husband died three years ago.”
“I know.”
“Are you saying the accidents were connected?”
“I’m saying someone sent me a photograph that should not exist, and your husband may have been one of the last people to see my family alive.”
Mia continued drawing. The scratch of her crayon sounded impossibly loud.
Vincent placed the photograph on the desk. “I need to know everything Daniel told you before he died.”
I looked at the image, at the familiar smile of the man I had loved, and remembered the last phone call he had made to me. His voice had been strained. He had told me not to wait up. Then, just before hanging up, he had said something I had spent years trying to forget.
“If anything happens, don’t trust the police report.”
I repeated those words aloud.
Vincent went utterly still.
Outside, a car engine started in the courtyard. Renzo moved toward the window and pulled the curtain aside. A black sedan was leaving through the east gate, although the security roster showed no scheduled departure.
Vincent reached for his phone. “Lock the gate,” he ordered. “And find out who is driving.”
The guard on the line hesitated. “Sir, the vehicle belongs to your brother, Matteo.”
Vincent looked at me, then at the photograph of Daniel.
“Of course it does,” he said.
May you like
The following afternoon, I found Renzo alone in the library. He was standing before a shelf of old family albums, one hand resting on a blue leather volume. When I asked if Vincent had always been so patient with children, he closed the book too quickly. He told me Vincent had once been the kind of father who carried spare hair ribbons in his jacket pocket and knew the names of every stuffed animal in his daughter's bedroom. Isabella had been four when the accident happened. She had loved making serious faces at her father, too, and Adriana had joked that the household contained two bosses who were equally stubborn. Renzo said all of this in a careful voice, then apologized for telling me more than he should. I told him that Mia's resemblance to Isabella's habits could be coincidence, not destiny. He nodded, but his eyes filled with an emotion he refused to name.
I thought about the conversation as I folded Mia's clothes that evening. A child cannot replace another child. No kindness from Vincent could make his daughter return, and I did not want Mia carrying the weight of his grief. The next morning, I planned to tell him that our arrangement needed clearer boundaries. But when Mia entered the study and announced she had brought him a paper medal for being brave enough to smile, he accepted it with such solemn gratitude that my speech deserted me. I realized the problem was not that he expected her to heal him. The problem was that all of us were beginning to hope for something we were afraid to describe.
Related Stories
