Chapter 4 - The Woman Who Came Back From the Dead—and the Daughter She Was Forbidden to Claim
By the time Diane reached her apartment building, she had forgotten the cold, the rain, and the fact that Ravi Greedy was following at a respectful distance. All she could hear was Mrs. Alvarez's voice repeating the impossible name.
Evelyn Voss.
The woman who had disappeared eighteen years ago. The woman holding a baby in the photograph. The woman who might have given birth to Diane.
Mrs. Alvarez stood at the top of the stairs in her house slippers, gripping the railing. Behind her, the apartment door was open. Sadi sat on the couch with her school backpack hugged to her chest. A stranger occupied the chair opposite her.
The stranger was perhaps forty-five, with silver threaded through dark hair and a face that seemed painfully familiar. She wore a plain navy coat. There was a small white scar near her eyebrow and a tremor in her left hand.
When she saw Diane, she stood so quickly the chair scraped the floor.
“Don't come closer,” Diane said.
The woman stopped.
“I'm not here to hurt you.”
“That's what people say before they ask for something.”
The woman accepted the accusation without protest. “My name is Evelyn. I knew Laura Harper.”
“You told Mrs. Alvarez you were Evelyn Voss.”
“I am.”
“Prove it.”
Evelyn reached into her coat. Ravi, who had stopped in the doorway, shifted slightly. She noticed and took her hand out empty.
“May I show you something?”
Diane nodded. Evelyn slowly removed a worn photograph from an inside pocket. It showed Laura Harper on a summer porch beside a dark-haired woman holding a baby. On the back, written in blue ink, were the words: For the day she asks why we left. E.
Diane's stomach tightened. Her mother had used that same blue ink to label every school lunch bag and birthday card.
“Photographs can be forged,” Diane said.
“Yes.” Evelyn put it on the table. “So can birth certificates. That's why you shouldn't trust me just because I look like you.”
Sadi looked between them. “Diane, is this the lady from the picture?”
“Go sit with Mrs. Alvarez for a minute, bug.”
“I can hear you through the wall anyway.”
“I know. But I need to ask questions you shouldn't have to answer.”
Sadi hesitated, then took Mrs. Alvarez's hand. Before leaving, she looked at Evelyn. “My mom was nice. If you knew her, don't say anything mean about her.”
Evelyn's eyes filled. “I wouldn't dare.”
When the door closed, Diane sat across from the woman. Ravi remained standing, not at her shoulder but near the entrance, where she could ask him to leave.
“Start with Laura,” Diane said. “Not with who you think I am.”
Evelyn folded her hands. “Laura worked as a nurse at a clinic funded by the Voss Foundation. Your father Daniel handled freight records for one of Edmund's companies. They discovered shipments of medical supplies being diverted to private buyers. The foundation reported the supplies as donations, then charged hospitals for replacements. Laura kept copies because children were missing treatments.”
“That part I know.”
“What you don't know is why Edmund feared her. She found the records of my daughter's disappearance.”
Diane's throat felt dry. “Your daughter?”
“I had a baby named Anna. Six months after she was born, Edmund told the world I'd run away with her. Then he told me she'd died.”
“Which was it?”
“Neither, I hope.”
“Hope?” Diane repeated. “You came here saying you knew me.”
“I came because your name appeared in the news after the gala. I saw your face and remembered Laura's promise. But I won't pretend I have proof that you're Anna.”
Diane stared at her. This restraint felt more disturbing than a dramatic declaration would have. Everyone else had arrived with certainty and orders. Evelyn had arrived with a question.
“Where have you been for eighteen years?”
“In a residential treatment facility under another name for part of it. After that, in towns where no one knew me. Edmund's people controlled my medication and my correspondence. When I finally got out, I was told Laura and Daniel were dead and that there was no one left to help.”
“Why didn't you go to the police?”
“I did. Twice. The first officer sent me back to my husband's attorney. The second listened, but I had no records and no one who would corroborate my story. I stopped trusting anyone with a badge.”
“Detective Chen isn't Edmund's officer.”
“I know that now. I contacted her this afternoon. She told me not to approach you without an appointment. I was afraid Edmund would find me before morning. That was wrong. I'm sorry.”
Ravi spoke for the first time. “Who told you Diane's address?”
Evelyn looked at him. “A woman who said she was Laura's friend. She called herself Nora.”
Ravi's expression hardened. “Describe her.”
“Red hair. Green raincoat. She said she worked at the clinic.”
Diane remembered the woman who had photographed Sadi outside school. In the image Detective Chen had shown her, the photographer's reflection was barely visible in a parked car window: a flash of green.
“Did Nora ask you to bring anything?” Diane asked.
“A letter.” Evelyn's hand shook as she reached into her coat again. This time she laid a sealed envelope on the table. It bore Diane's name in careful block letters.
“Don't open it,” Ravi said.
Diane turned toward him. “You don't get to decide.”
“I know. I meant we should photograph it first. It may be evidence.”
She took a breath. “Then say that.”
He nodded. “You're right.”
Diane called Detective Chen. The detective arrived with a uniformed officer and photographed the envelope before anyone touched it. Inside was a single sheet bearing an address and a sentence: Ask Evelyn what happened at the winter cabin. Come alone if you want the original hospital file.
There was no signature.
Evelyn went pale. “The cabin,” she whispered.
“What cabin?” Chen asked.
“Edmund kept a house outside Lake Geneva. He said it was where the family went to rest. He took me there after Anna disappeared.”
“Did you see your daughter there?”
“No. But I heard a baby crying in another room.”
The apartment seemed to shrink around them. Diane stared at the letter. Someone wanted her at a specific place. Someone who knew enough to terrify Evelyn.
Chen sealed the note. “Nobody is going to that address tonight. We'll verify ownership and request surveillance footage. Ms. Voss, I need a formal statement.”
Evelyn nodded, then looked at Diane. “You don't owe me anything. Not belief. Not forgiveness. Not even another conversation.”
“Then why come?”
“Because Laura saved a child when I couldn't. If that child was you, I wanted you to know she chose you every day.”
After Evelyn left with the detective, Diane sat beside Sadi on the couch. Her sister studied her face.
“Is she our aunt?”
“I don't know.”
“Is she your mom?”
“I don't know that either.”
Sadi thought for a moment. “If she is, does that mean Mom and Dad weren't ours?”
Diane wrapped an arm around her. “No. They were ours. Nothing can change that.”
Sadi leaned against her. “Good. Because I liked them.”
Diane kissed the top of her head and let herself cry quietly, not from despair but from the effort of holding so many truths without dropping any.
Later, Ravi waited by the stairwell while she locked the apartment door. He had arranged nothing without asking. She noticed the difference.
“Your people used to work with Edmund,” she said.
“Some still do. I'm trying to find out who.”
“Then why should I trust you?”
“You shouldn't trust me on reputation. Judge what I do.”
“Fine. Tell Detective Chen everything you know about the Voss shipments.”
“I already requested a meeting.”
“And don't send anyone to follow Sadi without telling me.”
“I won't.”
She watched him for a moment. “You looked frightened when you saw that letter.”
“I was.”
“Of Edmund?”
“No. Of recognizing the address.”
He showed her an old photograph on his phone. A cabin beside a frozen lake. Three men stood on the porch. One was Edmund Voss. One was Ravi's late father. The third wore a dark scarf over his mouth.
“Who is he?” Diane asked.
Ravi zoomed in on the man's hand. A ring with a black square stone caught the light.
“My father's business partner,” he said. “The man who arranged the accident that killed your parents.”
Diane gripped the railing. “You know his name?”
Ravi nodded, but his voice sounded unlike itself.
May you like
“Vincent Greedy. My uncle.”
TO BE CONTINUED IN CHAPTER 5
Related Stories
