Chapter 2 - THE MAFIA KING DEMANDED TO KNOW WHETHER THE TWINS WERE HIS—BUT HIS FORMER MAID REVEALED THE CRUEL BETRAYAL THAT HAD DESTROYED THEIR LOVE FIVE YEARS EARLIER

Natalie did not sleep after the gala. Noah and Lily finally settled into their shared bed, one clutching a toy truck, the other her one-eared rabbit. Their apartment was small enough that she could hear every breath from the kitchen table. She sat with a mug of tea she never drank and stared at Dominic's number.
She had imagined meeting him again hundreds of times. In some versions, she told him everything and he fell to his knees. In others, she walked past him as though he were a stranger. Never once had she imagined the children running across his ballroom while a room full of millionaires watched.
At seven the next morning, her phone rang. It was Mrs. Alvarez, the woman who had been hired to watch staff members' children during the gala.
“I'm sorry,” the older woman said. “A woman from the executive office told me your supervisor needed you upstairs. She said I should bring the children because the staff room was closing.”
“Did you recognize her voice?”
“No. But the caller knew their names.”
Natalie gripped the edge of the table. “Both names?”
“Yes. Noah and Lily. I thought she must be someone from the agency.”
After the call, Natalie checked the lock twice. She had spent years protecting the twins from ordinary dangers: traffic, fever, strangers, unpaid bills. Now the past had found them in a mansion full of guards.
At eight-thirty, Dominic called. He did not ask where she lived.
“I'm sorry to disturb you,” he said. “I wanted to know if the children are all right.”
“They're eating cereal.”
“Good.” A pause. “May I ask how you are?”
“Angry.”
“I deserve that.”
“You deserve to know why.”
“I'd like to listen.”
She nearly hung up. Listening was the one thing he had refused to do when it mattered. But there was something different in his voice: not command, not impatience, only uncertainty.
“Meet me at the public library on Ashland at noon,” she said. “Come alone. No security inside. The twins will be with my neighbor.”
“I'll be there.”
Dominic arrived ten minutes early, wearing a dark coat without a visible entourage. Natalie saw him through the library window, standing among parents pushing strollers and teenagers waiting for the doors to open. He looked out of place, which was perhaps the point.
They sat in a study room with a glass wall. Natalie had chosen it because she wanted witnesses nearby, not because she thought Dominic would hurt her, but because she no longer trusted the machinery surrounding him.
She placed a manila envelope on the table.
“This is what I tried to send you.”
Inside was a copy of a handwritten letter dated five years earlier. Dominic read the first line and went still.
Dominic, I don't know if you'll ever forgive me for something I didn't do, but I need you to know I'm pregnant.
He continued. Natalie watched his expression change as he read about the first ultrasound appointment, the fear of raising a baby alone, and her request that he speak to her before making any decisions. The letter did not demand money or marriage. It asked for one conversation.
At the bottom, beneath her signature, she had written: Whatever you believe about me, this child deserves the truth.
Dominic laid the page down with great care. “I never saw this.”
“I know.”
“How did you send it?”
“Certified mail to your office. It was signed for.” She produced a receipt. “Isabella's name is on it.”
He studied the signature. “She told me you'd accepted money to leave.”
Natalie laughed once, without humor. “What money?”
“She said she'd arranged a settlement.”
“I lived in a motel where the hot water worked every other day. I cleaned offices until my ankles swelled. Does that sound like a settlement?”
“No.”
“You believed her because it was convenient. You wanted the woman in the expensive suits, the one who knew which fork to use at a charity dinner. You wanted someone who wouldn't embarrass you.”
Dominic looked down. “I thought the evidence against you was real.”
“You didn't investigate it.”
“No.”
“You didn't even ask me what happened.”
“No.”
She leaned forward. “Then don't tell me Isabella destroyed us by herself. She lied. You chose to believe her.”
He met her eyes. “You're right.”
The answer disarmed her for an instant. She had prepared herself for denials, excuses, the cold certainty he had worn like armor five years ago. She had not prepared for agreement.
“I'm not asking you to forgive me,” he said. “I want to understand every part of what happened.”
Natalie told him about the day she discovered the pregnancy, about a clinic nurse who smiled when the ultrasound showed two heartbeats, about crying in a grocery-store parking lot because she could barely afford milk. She told him how a former coworker had found her a room, how she had learned to stretch soup across three meals, how she had held Noah and Lily against her chest on the night they were born and promised they would never feel unwanted.
Dominic listened without interrupting. When she described Lily's first steps and Noah's first word, he pressed his thumb against the edge of the table until the knuckle whitened.
“You missed everything,” Natalie said quietly. “Not because they were hidden in some distant country. Because you decided I wasn't worth one question.”
“I know.”
“You don't get to make it up by buying things.”
“I won't try.”
“And you don't get to announce you're their father before we know.”
“Agreed.”
She took a slow breath. “I want a DNA test. A real one, not something controlled by your family.”
“So do I. You choose the accredited laboratory and the attorney who handles consent. I'll pay the cost without choosing the people.”
Natalie studied him. “And if the test confirms it?”
“Then I'll ask what the children need from me. I'll seek legal advice about doing this properly. I won't take them from you.”
“You could.”
“I have resources,” he said. “That doesn't give me the right.”
She wanted to believe him. Wanting was not the same as trusting.
Dominic opened his coat pocket and took out a folded sheet. “Luca found the message that brought the children into the ballroom. It came from Isabella's office. She denies sending it.”
“Of course she does.”
“There's more. The note said I should see Noah first.”
Natalie went cold. “Why Noah?”
“I don't know. But someone knew his appearance would matter to me.”
She thought of the boy's gray eyes and Lily's familiar smile. “Then someone has been watching us.”
“That's possible. I don't want to frighten you with guesses.”
“It's a little late for that.”
Dominic nodded. “Luca is preserving the office records. An independent investigator will review them.”
Natalie hesitated, then said, “There's something else. Six months after the twins were born, a woman came to my apartment. She said she worked for a private legal office. She offered me a large amount of money to sign a document saying the father was unknown.”
Dominic's face tightened. “Did you sign?”
“No. She left when I asked for identification.”
“Do you remember her name?”
“She called herself Ms. Bell. I kept the business card.”
Natalie reached into the envelope and withdrew a small cream card. The printed number was disconnected, but the embossed emblem in the corner—a narrow silver tower—made Dominic straighten.
“What?” Natalie asked.
“I've seen that emblem.”
“Where?”
“On correspondence from a private firm Isabella recommended for confidential family matters.”
The silence between them deepened.
At the mansion, Isabella Russo was having a much worse morning than she expected. She stood in Dominic's study facing Luca Ferraro, who had asked for access to the executive communications archive.
“You answer to Dominic,” she said. “Not to me.”
“Correct,” Luca replied. “He authorized the review.”
“Then he should tell me himself.”
“He has.”
Isabella reached for her phone. Luca did not move. He simply waited while she called Dominic and received no answer.
“I have spent five years protecting this family,” she said.
“Then the records should protect you,” Luca answered.
After he left, Isabella closed the study door and dialed a number she had not used in months.
“The children were seen,” she said when someone answered.
A man's voice replied, “That wasn't the plan.”
“I know what the plan was.”
“Then why did you change it?”
“I didn't.”
A long silence followed. “Someone wants you blamed.”
Isabella stared at the dark window. For the first time, she wondered whether she had become expendable to the people she had helped.
Back at the library, Natalie and Dominic arranged the testing appointment. She chose a clinic affiliated with a university hospital and insisted the collection happen with both parties present and verified identification. Dominic agreed to every condition.
“Why didn't you marry Isabella?” Natalie asked suddenly.
He looked startled. “We never became engaged.”
“Everyone thought you would.”
“She wanted that. I let people assume it because it made business gatherings easier.”
“Did you love her?”
Dominic took time before answering. “I trusted her judgment. I admired her ambition. I confused those things with something deeper.”
Natalie looked away. “You used to say love was the one thing you couldn't fake.”
“I remember.”
“Then you should have known.”
He accepted the blow. “I should have.”
Outside, snow began to fall against the library windows. Natalie remembered a winter evening five years earlier when Dominic had made her hot chocolate in the mansion kitchen because she was shivering after carrying groceries through the garden. He had stood barefoot in a room full of expensive appliances, grinning when he burned the milk. That memory had sustained her during the first lonely months. Now it felt dangerous.
“Don't look at me like that,” she whispered.
“Like what?”
“Like you can see the woman I was.”
“I can,” he said. “But I'm beginning to understand the woman you became.”
She gathered her papers. “I have to pick up the children.”
Dominic rose. “May I ask something about them? Nothing important. Just something small.”
Natalie paused.
“What makes Lily laugh?”
She almost smiled. “Bad jokes. The worse the joke, the louder she laughs.”
“And Noah?”
“He likes maps. He wants to know how roads connect. He draws cities with crayons and makes sure every building has a door.”
Dominic's expression broke. His mother had collected maps of cities she hoped to visit. He had loved drawing roads as a boy. The resemblance was not proof, but it felt like a whisper from the past.
“Thank you,” he said.
She left before he could say more.
That afternoon, Dominic called his attorney, a woman named Evelyn Park who had represented his legitimate businesses for a decade and never flinched at his temper. He told her everything, including his own failure to investigate the original accusation.
“You need to understand something,” Evelyn said. “Parentage is one question. Trust is another. If you pressure Natalie, you'll damage both.”
“I know.”
“Do you? Because your instinct when you're afraid is to control the room.”
He looked at the photograph of his mother. “Then I'll have to learn another instinct.”
Evelyn arranged for an independent review of the five-year-old allegations against Natalie. She also asked Luca to preserve all original electronic records and keep a documented chain of custody. Dominic had no intention of using threats to solve this. He wanted facts that could survive daylight.
By evening, Luca returned with an unexpected discovery. The confidential documents Natalie had supposedly leaked had been copied from a workstation assigned to Isabella's assistant, not from Natalie's access card. A security report identifying that workstation had been marked resolved and removed from Dominic's briefing packet.
“Who removed it?” Dominic asked.
“We're checking. But the approval code belongs to your uncle, Victor Moretti.”
Dominic felt the old family machinery grinding into view. Victor had managed internal security when Dominic first took over the organization. He had been the man who advised Dominic never to trust servants with family secrets.
“Bring Evelyn into this,” Dominic said. “No accusations until we have the originals.”
His phone vibrated. A message from Natalie appeared.
The children are asleep. I found another letter I never mailed. I think you should read it before the test.
Dominic typed: Whenever you're ready.
A photograph followed. It showed a folded page covered in Natalie's handwriting. He zoomed in and read the final paragraph.
If our baby has your eyes, I hope you'll see them one day and understand that love was never the betrayal. The betrayal was letting someone else tell you who I was.
Dominic lowered the phone. He had spent five years believing he was the injured party. Now he understood that his silence had injured people who had never even been born when he made his choice.
A second message arrived, this one from an unknown number.
STOP LOOKING INTO THE OLD FILES. THE TWINS ARE SAFER WHEN THE PAST STAYS BURIED.
Dominic forwarded it to Evelyn and Luca. Then he called Natalie.
“Have you received anything strange?” he asked.
She was silent for a beat. “Someone left an envelope under my door.”
“What was inside?”
“A photograph of Noah and Lily at their playground. Taken yesterday.”
Dominic stood so quickly his chair struck the wall.
On the back, Natalie said, someone had written six words.
May you like
THEIR FATHER CANNOT PROTECT THEM.
END OF CHAPTER 2.
Related Stories