Chapter 2 - The Stolen Caravaggio Masterpiece, the Red Hook Safehouse Confrontation, and the Terrifying Underworld Boss Who Refused to Let Her GoThe painting in the box was not a reproduction.
It was the true, long-lost Calling of Saint Matthew study that had vanished from a private Roman collection in 1969—the very masterpiece every museum in Europe had spent decades hunting.
Resting in the corner of the velvet-lined box was a small, white card bearing elegant, handwritten cursive:
You deserve authentic art, Sienna. Not forgeries. Not substitutes. Come and tell me what else you see.—M.
Sienna’s hands trembled as she covered the canvas. Mateo hadn't just sent her a priceless artifact; he had essentially dropped a multi-million-dollar museum piece onto her kitchen counter like a calling card, proving with terrifying clarity that no gallery vault, no private collector, and no law enforcement agency could keep secrets from him.
By Friday evening, the terror had curdled into fierce, uncompromising anger. She was not a possession to be bought with smuggled antiquities or guarded like a prize stallion in a stable. If Mateo Romano wanted her out of his life, or if he wanted answers, he was going to get them face-to-face.
She hailed a cab and gave the driver an address in Red Hook—a desolate stretch of container terminals and rusted warehouses where the Romano Syndicate operated its true logistics empire.
When the cab dropped her outside a nondescript, heavily reinforced brick warehouse bearing the faded logo Romano Imports, the iron gates swung open automatically before she even reached the keypad.
Two armed enforcers clad in dark suits stepped out of the shadows, their eyes scanning her with clinical detachment. But before either of them could speak, the metal side door clicked open.
Mateo stood on the threshold.
He had shed his suit jacket, wearing a crisp white dress shirt with the sleeves rolled up to his forearms, revealing the dark, powerful muscles of a man who commanded the streets by force. His dark eyes flared with surprise, quickly morphing into a deep, possessive heat as he looked at her standing alone in the chilly autumn wind.
“You shouldn't be here, Sienna,” Mateo said, his low, rough baritone vibrating through the open air. “This place is not safe for you.”
“Nothing is safe for me as long as you keep treating my life like your private chessboard!” Sienna fired back, marching right up to him, her eyes flashing with fury. She jabbed a finger against his solid chest. “You ruined Preston’s career because he asked me out to dinner?! You had a stolen Caravaggio delivered to my brownstone like it was a bouquet of roses?! What is wrong with you?!”
Mateo didn't flinch. He didn't raise his voice. He simply looked down at her with a terrifying, unyielding intensity that made her breath catch.
“He was unworthy of you,” Mateo stated simply, as if explaining a basic law of physics. “He looked at you as a social accessory for weekend galas. I look at you as my entire world. There is a vast difference.”
“I don't care about your world!” Sienna yelled, though her voice faltered slightly against the raw, absolute devotion burning in his dark eyes. “I am an art authenticator! I live a quiet, normal life! I don't want a mafia capo tracking my coffee orders and upending my social circle!”
“Normal life ended the moment you looked at me across that ballroom and didn't look away,” Mateo growled, his patience finally snapping.
He reached out, his strong hands catching her waist, and hauled her across the threshold into the warehouse, kicking the heavy metal door shut behind them with a resounding clack that locked them inside the dimly lit, vaulted interior.
Before Sienna could protest, Mateo pulled her flush against his chest, trapping her against his solid frame. The scent of rain, scotch, and Ombré Leather wrapped around her like a physical cage.
“You said not yet,” Mateo murmured, his lips brushing dangerously close to her ear, his voice dropping into a husky, hypnotic register. “Every second since you spoke those words, my blood has burned with the need to make you mine permanently. You think you can walk away from this? Try.”
May you like
Sienna stared up at him, her heart hammering against her ribs in a chaotic rhythm of terror and intoxicating desire. She wanted to fight him, to push him away, to prove she wouldn't bend to his underworld gravity. But when his dark eyes searched hers with a hunger so fierce it felt sacred, all the angry words dissolved on her tongue.
Instead of pushing him away, her hands slid up his chest, gripping the lapels of his shirt as her lips parted, silently surrendering to the storm she had unlocked.
